Improving the policy capability and performance in India

-

Improving the policy capability and performance in India


 

Policy making and implementation and management should be integrated and aligned in order to carry out the strategic intent of the government.  In India we have top down policy making. In top down policy making, authorities must have clear objectives, clear communication between different layers of governments and strong knowledge base about the problem (Mulgan & Lee 2001). But practically this never happens. Policy makers are not aware of the real world and communication gap exist between policy makers and implementers. This gap results in an over enthusiasm about the capacity of the change to be infinite, which in reality will be finite along with underestimated risks.

 

 


My one suggestion for improving the policy capability and performance is to reduce the gap in communication between policy makers and implementers. Many policies and programs face practical difficulties while implementing which may not be expected by the policy makers or decision makers. For instance, road traffic policy of building a foot over bridge may be good and feasible while studying. But on implementation it was found difficult to implement because a group of shop owners objected to it as it will reduce their business as well as it will uglify the spot and block the view of buildings. Better communications between all levels of the system and those involved in policy development and implementation can reduce the chance for failures. Nowadays web-based tools are available that link together many players involved in a change process. These tools will allow the stakeholders to participate in the whole process from design through implementation to review and improvement.



 

According to Scott & Baehler (2010) performance can be improved by applying insights from regular monitoring and reviewing of policies. Scott & Baehler, (2010) also states that in most cases the focus of government is on outputs and short-term political advantages rather than outcomes which is true in Indian scenario. In India, monitoring of the financial aspects of implementation are done rather than the effectiveness of the policy in delivering the outcomes. Also, no evaluation of the outcomes, especially medium-term and long-term outcomes are done in India. For policies to be effective in achieving outcomes that deliver value to the citizen, the entire system must function well. Every new initiative need a built-in capacity to learn, for monitoring and evaluation. This may involve horizontal networks to allow sharing of best practices. Lessons learned units in departments to quickly identify emerging solutions and issues give quick feedback to policy makers. A machinery for monitoring enable quick adjustment of priorities, resources and targets. Outcomes should be assessed with reference to professional standards.  For evaluation, correct data and information is needed. The data and information available are limited or not adequate and sometimes suppressed. A knowledge pool by collecting evidence on implementation and delivering and publicising it to solicit reviews by all concerned stakeholders is to be encouraged. Lessons learned exercise carried out after implementation would ensure that mistakes are not repeated. However, everyone should be tolerant to unexpected results and ready to learn from the results.

 

Reference

Mulgan and Lee (2001). Better Policy Delivery and Design:

Scott, C., & Baehler, K. (2010). Adding Value to Policy Analysis.

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Poisonous bird- Hooded pitohui the only known bird to be toxic,

-
Image
Poisonous birds! Yes, they exist. Hooded pitohui the only known bird to be toxic, Picture courtesy Google images There are many poisonous insects and reptiles all over the world. But have you ever heard of a bird that can be poisonous? If you ever visit the forests of New Guinea, and you come upon a beautiful orange and black hooded pitohui bird, just enjoy its singing from a distance. Do not attempt to handle it. This bird is better off in the bush than in the hand The Hooded Pitohui (pronounced pit-o-hooey) is a songbird found in the rain forests of New Guinea, an island which lies in the South Pacific Ocean to the east of Indonesia. There are around six species of Pitohui of which the Hooded Pitohui is the most deadly. Declared to be the ‘Most Poisonous Bird’ by the Guinness Book of World Records, it was discovered in 1989 by an American biologist Jack Dumbacher who was netting birds in New Guinea. In 1989, Jack Dumbacher travelled to the Papua New Guinea bush in search of birds
Read more

Interesting facts about New Zealand

-
Image
  New Zealand is a beautiful island nation in the southwestern Pacific Ocean comprising two main landmasses—the North Island and the South Island separated by the waters of the Cook Strait. South Island is the larger of the two islands. There are also about 600 smaller islands. The largest of these islands is Rakiura island, also referred to as Stewart Island.  Wellington is the capital of New Zealand, and Auckland is the most populous city. Both are located on the North Island.    In 1642, Dutch explorer Abel Tasman became the first European to sight New Zealand. In 1840, representatives of the United Kingdom and Māori chiefs signed the Treaty of Waitangi, which declared British sovereignty over the islands. In 1841, New Zealand became a colony within the British Empire and in 1907 it became a dominion; it gained full statutory independence in 1947. However, the British monarch remained the head of state.  New Zealand is known for its stunning natural beauty, incredible Maori culture,
Read more